Squishy Forum -pamie.com
  Love and Sex
  Boxers or Briefs? (Page 4)

Post New Topic  Post A Reply
profile | register | preferences | faq | search

UBBFriend: Email This Page to Someone!
This topic is 5 pages long:   1  2  3  4  5 
next newest topic | next oldest topic
Author Topic:   Boxers or Briefs?
TightyWhityMan
Squishite
posted May 09, 2001 02:16 PM    
quote:
Originally posted by brie:
zoinks, kids, it's just underwear!

damn! i've never seen so many people get so upset over something as silly as undies!!!


IS it just underwear?

IP: Logged

TightyWhityMan
Squishite
posted May 09, 2001 02:19 PM    
quote:
Originally posted by Jessa33:

Okay, if a girl is dumping you over your underwear, she needs a life. It really shouldn't be a deal breaker.


Gotta agree with you here.

[This message has been edited by TightyWhityMan (edited May 09, 2001).]

IP: Logged

TightyWhityMan
Squishite
posted May 09, 2001 02:21 PM    
quote:
Originally posted by Jessa33:


How many hours does anyone spend looking at someone else's underwear?


In my experience, some women delight in a man's underwear.

IP: Logged

TightyWhityMan
Squishite
posted May 09, 2001 02:24 PM    
quote:
Originally posted by Nihilisa:
I'd say they'd be more attractive if they weren't white, but men have a hard time pulling off purple tighties.

Purple tighties! Now THAT'S HOT! That was one of my high school colors. Gonna hunt me down a pair 'o them suckas right now! That should drive her bonkers.

[This message has been edited by TightyWhityMan (edited May 09, 2001).]

IP: Logged

TightyWhityMan
Squishite
posted May 09, 2001 03:01 PM    
quote:
Originally posted by Nihilisa:
Personally, when I see a man in tighty whiteys, I think, "god, I feel like I'm sleeping with a ten year old. I hope he doesn't want me to pack his lunch now."

[...]So, I just try to avert my eyes until he either takes them off, or puts on some jeans.



Nihilisa, I really appreciate your frankness about how you react to tighty whities. That kind of honesty is what I've asked for. But at the same time it's kind of sad you have to "avert your eyes." You're missing out on something. When a man lets a woman see him in tighty whities, it's like he's saying, "Yeah, I'm this big, tough man, but now I'm casting aside my toughness, because I trust you, and you can trust me. I have a pure heart for you." On a grown man, they're not a sign of childhood innocence; they signify an ingenuousness and readiness on his part to sacrifice his ego to a melding of two egos. That's what I HOPE MY tighty whities say to a woman, anyway. I don't think bright orange silk boxers with red lobsters, or stylish black boxer briefs with a fancy designer's name around the waistband, can really quite say this. They say: Hey, I'm Studley Dudley! Look at me! We'll get to you another time." Think about it the next time you see your husband in his lowly tighty whities, and ask yourself if you can't see it this way for a moment.

[This message has been edited by TightyWhityMan (edited May 09, 2001).]

IP: Logged

TightyWhityMan
Squishite
posted May 09, 2001 03:19 PM    
quote:
Originally posted by eac:
oh, lordy...

TWM, i'm right up there with ErikZ. make a choice, and move on. i find it fascinting (in a scary way) that you're adamant you love this woman, you rarely if ever change your opinion, and you're quite attached to your TWs - but for some reason, you're conducting a public poll on opinions, as if that will make a difference. seriously - if 50 women here said we're disgusted beyond belief by TWs, would you stop wearing them? why would our opinions be more important than the opinion of the woman you love, or your own opinion?

good god. who knew that underwear was a burning philosophical morass?



More than anything, I think I want to understand WHY at least many women seem repulsed by something that to me is basic, and essentially good. For some reason I'm convinced there's more to it than the women here are saying. Why do you say my interest is fascinating "(in a scary way)"? What's scary about it? Is it like I'm stepping on some hidden nerve? Violating some taboo? Threatening some hidden, deeply-held but unfounded, unwarranted, belief? Is it just that you can't understand why someone would really care to spend more than a moment on these silly questions? Isn't it at least equally scary that a garment that has--like it or not--been a mainstay of male attire, in the U.S and elsewhere--makes women want to gag?

IP: Logged

TightyWhityMan
Squishite
posted May 09, 2001 03:22 PM    
quote:
Originally posted by TightyWhityMan:
[QUOTE]Originally posted by eac:
[b]oh, lordy...

TWM, i'm right up there with ErikZ. make a choice, and move on. i find it fascinting (in a scary way) that you're adamant you love this woman, you rarely if ever change your opinion, and you're quite attached to your TWs - but for some reason, you're conducting a public poll on opinions, as if that will make a difference. seriously - if 50 women here said we're disgusted beyond belief by TWs, would you stop wearing them? why would our opinions be more important than the opinion of the woman you love, or your own opinion?

good god. who knew that underwear was a burning philosophical morass?



More than anything, I think I want to understand WHY at least many women seem repulsed by something that to me is basic, and essentially good. For some reason I'm convinced there's more to it than the women here are saying. Why do you say my interest is fascinating "(in a scary way)"? What's scary about it? Is it like I'm stepping on some hidden nerve? Violating some taboo? Threatening some hidden, deeply-held but unfounded, unwarranted, belief? Is it just that you can't understand why someone would really care to spend more than a moment on these silly questions? Isn't it at least equally scary that a garment that has--like it or not--been a mainstay of male attire, in the U.S and elsewhere, makes many women want to gag? By the way, are there ANY women out there who not only tolerate tighty whities, or think tighty whities are "OKAY, but..."--but who actually LOVE tighty whities or at least can say they like tighty whities better than any other kind of men's underwear?[/B][/QUOTE]

IP: Logged

GAChick
Squishaholic
posted May 09, 2001 04:31 PM    
OK, I know we're beating a dead horse here, but if you want to know why I find them repulsive, I think it's because they're just basically unflattering on most men. Like any tight clothing, they accentuate everything. Just from a fashion standpoint, high cut legs (bikini briefs of either gender) or longer legs (like boxers or boxer briefs) are almost always more flattering to the legs and hips than something with low cut legs (like men's briefs or granny panties - no offense to granny panty wearers, I'm speaking in broad sweeping generalizaitons here). I think the only good thing about them is that they do accentuate a nice butt, and I freely admit that I am a butt woman. They just don't do anything positive for the view from the front.

[This message has been edited by GAChick (edited May 09, 2001).]

IP: Logged

PackAnimal
Squishite
posted May 10, 2001 02:09 PM    
quote:
Originally posted by TightyWhityMan: More than anything, I think I want to understand why...


TWM, you're freaking everybody out. Calm down. Get a grip.

I at least admire you for having the balls to tell us how proud you are of wearing the underwear that chicks gag at the sight of and most guys give up before their voices change.

But it sounds like at this point you're really NOT all that sure this is the underwear for you. You want to make the transition from boxers to briefs, as every guy at some point should, and you're just looking for a little encouragement. Or should I say a LOT of encouragement? If you're extra-sensitive, why don't you invest in some better-quality boxers, made of softer cotton? For workouts try some different brands of boxer briefs. They don't all fit the same. Make sure the ones you get for workouts are tight enough where it counts. Get a smaller size for more support. Also, when wearing boxers, practice moving with better coordination so you don't hurt yourself. It's a skill you have to LEARN.

Ladies: harsh on this guy's huggies! Yeah, he's got a bad-ass attitude, but I think basically he's just begging you to tell him what he already knows but hasn't managed to accept--YET: tighty whities are for little boys and dorks. Women hate them.

Guys: if any other of you still wear tighty whities, how about taking the boxer challenge along with TightyWhityMan? Give him the moral support he needs to have the enjoyment of hanging loose and free, as every adult male should.

[This message has been edited by PackAnimal (edited May 10, 2001).]

IP: Logged

PackAnimal
Squishite
posted May 10, 2001 02:24 PM    
Boxers=Happiness

[This message has been edited by PackAnimal (edited May 10, 2001).]

IP: Logged

ChristopherTheOne
Forum Diva
posted May 10, 2001 02:34 PM    
quote:
Originally posted by PackAnimal:
Guys: if any other of you still wear tighty whities, how about taking the boxer challenge along with TightyWhityMan? Give him the moral support he needs to have the enjoyment of hanging loose and free, as every adult male should.

Ummm, no. I don't really care for that floppy feeling at all. Sometimes I'll go commando, but it's rare. I like support for the boys...no other way to say it.

As I've said before, though, the briefs are only for the gym (or when I need to do laundry), and even then, they aren't white. 90% of the time, boxer briefs are the selection.

IP: Logged

TightyWhityMan
Squishite
posted May 10, 2001 02:56 PM    
quote:
Originally posted by PackAnimal:
Guys: if any other of you still wear tighty whities, how about taking the boxer challenge along with TightyWhityMan? Give him the moral support he needs to have the enjoyment of hanging loose and free, as every adult male should.

Do you work for an underwear company?

[This message has been edited by TightyWhityMan (edited May 10, 2001).]

IP: Logged

TightyWhityMan
Squishite
posted May 10, 2001 03:03 PM    
quote:
Originally posted by tixin:

as for the hygiend skid marks?...it's all about farts...you can triple wipe and things are cool, but once you start laying out some beefy air nuggets, things get cruddy.

and what do I prefer? bikini's...string bikinis (see walmart)...and an occasional male specific thong (has a pocket/pouch for the jewels). why? cause if a chick can feel sexy, and whereing this stuff makes ME feel sexy, I'm gonna do it. If a mate asked me to wear silk boxers over my head, I'd do it for her, so long as I was aloud to go casual anyway I liked.

thanks....(and the tighywhite freak is VERY scary)



Your post speaks for itself.

IP: Logged

Vanyel
Squishite
posted May 10, 2001 05:06 PM    
wow, i've seen some weird shit on message boards, but this one takes the cake so far..

well, at least this week.

um, just for my own .02 worth, i like briefs and boxers. I enjoy the level of support from briefs when i go dancing or running or whatever (its, i'm assuming, like a bra for women, keeps all the extra bits from bouncing around painfully) but mine are never ever white. probably doesn't help much, but i do go for colours. the rest of the time i either wear boxers or nothing.

Oh, except when Kali (friend/lover/generally un-catagorical) wants me to wear panties. but that's a totally different story.

IP: Logged

leigha
Benefactor
posted May 10, 2001 05:13 PM    
quote:
Originally posted by ChristopherTheOne:
Ummm, no. I don't really care for that floppy feeling at all. Sometimes I'll go commando, but it's rare. I like support for the boys...no other way to say it.

As I've said before, though, the briefs are only for the gym (or when I need to do laundry), and even then, they aren't white. 90% of the time, boxer briefs are the selection.


See, this is why we got along so well. He understands my hatred of those nasty briefs. Although, he did used to have some silk boxers....

IP: Logged

PackAnimal
Squishite
posted May 12, 2001 01:47 PM    
quote:
Originally posted by TightyWhityMan:
Do you work for an underwear company?


No.

IP: Logged

Glitterbeam
Hardcore Squishite
posted May 12, 2001 03:58 PM    
quote:
Originally posted by TightyWhityMan:
IS it just underwear?


Ummm...yeah.
And since you seem to be taking some kind of sick survey, count me in as a boxer girl. I think you should give up.

IP: Logged

starlight
Winner
posted May 12, 2001 05:13 PM    
hrm...this thread scares me. nonetheless...

bring in another for boxers. first guy I liked wore em and wore em well.

IP: Logged

Jillo
Science is Tight
posted May 12, 2001 09:07 PM    
Depends on the guy. On my ex I preferred him with briefs, but with my current bf defeintley boxers.

I can't tell when a guy is weraing boxers or breifs unless I can see the strap around the waist.

IP: Logged

Brave_Brave_Sir_Garrick
Squishite
posted May 12, 2001 10:01 PM    
Personally, I think you're all being too hard on TWM. If you neglected to read the sign on the door, let me fill you in: The forum asks for your opinion on underwear, not the state of other's sanity. (Don't take any offence to that last comment, TWM, none was meant).

As for me, my drawer has Boxers, Briefs and Boxer Briefs in them, I just pull one out at random each morning.

For TWM: You seem to have gotten into a humourous situation with your girlfriend. Just ignore her 'threats' it'll blow over.

IP: Logged

ErikZ
Punk Ass Bitch
posted May 14, 2001 04:15 PM    
Sort of off topic.

I finally graduated college last Saturday.
I'm a sort of recluse. I'm working on getting better but new crowds or situations that are not under my control still freak me out.
So there I was, getting all tense and freaky about having to do the ceremony, stuffed in a small hot room with 500 other graduates when I thought about TightyWhityMan. That despite all the pressure I was putting myself under, the whole thing just wasn't that important. Then I laughed and relaxed. Well, not completely relaxed, but it sure did knock it down a few notches.

So thanks TWM, I hope you find that inner peace someday too.

IP: Logged

TightyWhityMan
Squishite
posted May 14, 2001 06:05 PM    
quote:
Originally posted by PackAnimal:
You want to make the transition from boxers to briefs, as every guy at some point should, and you're just looking for a little encouragement.

Are you a sociologist, urban anthropologist or space alien?

IP: Logged

pamie
Head Princess
posted May 14, 2001 08:07 PM    
How did I not see this thread until now?

TWM, when you want to reply to people, please try and make all of your replies in one post. Thanks.

IP: Logged

Jessifer
Bob
posted May 14, 2001 10:26 PM    
only once have i ever liked the look of briefs and holy damn, after gabe, no guy will ever look as good in tighty whiteys. i prefer boxers and depending on the guy, boxer briefs. either way, it's only underwear.

[This message has been edited by Jessifer (edited May 14, 2001).]

IP: Logged

SummerRose
Superstar
posted May 15, 2001 09:42 AM    
I prefer boxers. However my boyfriend wears boxer-briefs. I've gotten used to them so they're ok. I hate briefs though. I don't know why... maybe cuz it doesn't have easy access..

IP: Logged

*Gemini*
Superstar
posted May 15, 2001 12:38 PM    
SummerRose,
You are so my bitch...my thoughts exactly.Boxers are just sexier. There's something about a man in briefs that gives me the heebie-jeebies.Sorry..

IP: Logged

PackAnimal
Squishite
posted May 15, 2001 01:53 PM    
Originally posted by TightyWhityMan:
"Are you a sociologist, urban anthropologist or space alien?"

None of the above.

[This message has been edited by PackAnimal (edited May 15, 2001).]

IP: Logged

TightyWhityMan
Squishite
posted May 16, 2001 02:46 PM    
quote:
Originally posted by pamie:
How did I not see this thread until now?

TWM, when you want to reply to people, please try and make all of your replies in one post. Thanks.



Gotcha, Princess. So what sort of skivvies do you like to see on a man? How do you feel about tighty whities?
Gemini (May 15), can you say WHY briefs give you the "Heebie-jeebies"? Do white ones and colored ones both give you the creeps? Equally?
Jessifer (May 14), are you saying that on the right guy, tighty whities are actually good?
PackAnimal (May 15), are you actually my girlfriend, incognito, pretending to be a more-or-less-friendly-advice-giving guy, in order to dissuade me from wearing the underwear I know to be superior to any other kind?
Eac (can't remember when), you asked me "if 50 women here said we're disgusted beyond belief by TWs, would you stop wearing them?"
No, I wouldn't. 50 isn't a very large number for this context. But if 1,000 women told me this, then I'd have to. I do respect female opinion, but not the imperious whim of one quirky girlfriend. I've continued asking women about their men's underwear preference, and now I'm discovering that a lot of women in the 25-and-younger age bracket like tighty whities best. (Can you prove me wrong?) I'm noticing a correlation between pierced belly-buttons and tighty-whitey-liking.
ErikZ - congrats on graduating. Glad to hear thinking of me brought you some peace of mind at that stressful moment.

[This message has been edited by TightyWhityMan (edited May 16, 2001).]

IP: Logged

WriterGirl
Squishaholic
posted May 16, 2001 03:35 PM    
TWM, I can tell you personally that my boxer preference has been shaped by the sartorial choices of previous boyfriends. Bad associations, so to speak.

Were I ever to fall in love with a man in briefs, I might change my mind. (The Smoker is all about the boxers -- a very wise choice for his body shape.)

IP: Logged

Jessifer
Bob
posted May 16, 2001 04:08 PM    
quote:
Originally posted by TightyWhityMan:

Jessifer (May 14), are you saying that on the right guy, tighty whities are actually good?


yes, altho i've only ever seen one guy they looked good on. not that i see all that many guys in tighty whities. *ahem*

IP: Logged

Beatrice
Forum Whore
posted May 16, 2001 06:28 PM    
Mmmm.....Boxer briefs....drool...

IP: Logged

TightyWhityMan
Squishite
posted May 18, 2001 02:28 PM    
quote:
Originally posted by Beatrice:
Mmmm.....Boxer briefs....drool...

What about the phrase "Mmmm.....Tighty whities....drool..."? Do any of the women here go along with that?
Jessifer, what exactly do you mean by "*ahem*"? Are you saying that tighty whities are not generally the underwear most men choose to wear? Women at times are very subtle communicators, but at times this subtlety verges on inscrutability.

[This message has been edited by TightyWhityMan (edited May 18, 2001).]

IP: Logged

Jessifer
Bob
posted May 18, 2001 03:35 PM    
well, no, tighty whities aren't what most men choose to wear. but i was referring more to the amount of guys i end up seeing in their underwear, hence the *ahem* more like a ok-i'm-shutting-up-about-guy's-undies ahem.
but like i said before, IT'S JUST UNDERWEAR.

IP: Logged

Sir_Garrick
Squishite
posted May 18, 2001 10:24 PM    
quote:
Originally posted by TightyWhityMan:

What about the phrase "Mmmm.....Tighty whities....drool..."? Do any of the women here go along with that?
Jessifer, what exactly do you mean by "*ahem*"? Are you saying that tighty whities are not generally the underwear most men choose to wear? Women at times are very subtle communicators, but at times this subtlety verges on inscrutability.

[This message has been edited by TightyWhityMan (edited May 18, 2001).]


Aw geez, come on TWM, you're freakin' ME out here, and I don't easily freak.

Anyway, are you and your girlfriend still together? If not, why do you still care about this topic?


Anyway... something I don't get is why ladies associate white with childish... wouldn't colored briefs be childisher ( )?

[This message has been edited by Sir_Garrick (edited May 18, 2001).]

IP: Logged

WikerGirl
Rockstar
posted May 19, 2001 07:44 AM    
How did I miss this until today?

My word.

At any rate, boxers, and maybe boxer briefs, are my vote. I really don't like the look of briefs. At all.

IP: Logged

Daisy Bird
Insomniac
posted May 19, 2001 08:55 AM    
quote:
Originally posted by TightyWhityMan:
I do respect female opinion, but not the imperious whim of one quirky girlfriend.

This thread cracks me up.

I can't say that I have a large preference for any type of underwear on a man, mostly because the men I know don't spend a large amount of time lounging in them so my impressions are fleeting.

I can venture to say though, that briefs seem less attractive and more childish precisely because they are the underwear boys grow up wearing. This means lots of impressions, in my head at least, of little boys in white briefs. Seeing it large scale (so to speak) is rather like seeing grown up women in schoolgirl uniforms, or some similar little girl garb. And while this can be sexy in its own way, it's more by implicating a contrast of the grown up with the child, and in the case of schoolgirl uniforms, a little bit of a fetish as far as I have heard. So, I would assume it would take an adjustment to re-think the briefs as men's, rather than boy's underwear. Or, you could move to boxers or boxer briefs. It's the same for women, really. You think little girls wear the underwear grown women wear? I think Victoria's Secret is almost a rite of passage nowadays. But that could just have been me and my friends.

Anyway, the quote above alarmed me a little. It seems that your girlfriend's opinion should matter more than what 1,000 other women say, precisely because she is your girlfriend. And it doesn't seem right to call her opinion an "imperious whim". It seems to me that no matter how strange a request you think your girlfriend is making, if she feels that strongly about it, it should be treated with respect. Even if a million other people don't think that way, it's still a true feeling she has and a million other people won't discredit that. It's like saying a thousand other people don't like sushi, so you're not going to have it even though I like it.

And try to put this around on you. How would you feel if you hated something about her that she felt strongly about and refused to change? Say it was seeing an old boyfriend who was now a friend, but you thought he was a little too attached still. How would you feel if she said none of her other friends thought that, so she was ignoring your "imperious whim"?

I'm not saying that underwear is on the same level as exes, but that the opinion is. Obviously both of you have strong feelings about underwear, so that's where it goes in this case. But how you treat that opinion each of you have about the underwear should really be the focus IMHO, not the connotations behind different types of underwear, though it's been fun to read about.

Hope that helps. I really had to post in the underwear thread since it makes me smile.

IP: Logged

PackAnimal
Squishite
posted May 19, 2001 01:29 PM    
quote:
Originally posted by TightyWhityMan:
PackAnimal (May 15), are you actually my girlfriend, incognito, pretending to be a more-or-less-friendly-advice-giving guy, in order to dissuade me from wearing the underwear I know to be superior to any other kind?[/B]

Sorry, big guy.

IP: Logged

Elana
Squishite
posted May 20, 2001 10:43 AM    
personally i perfer guys in boxers or boxer breifs.(or nothing at all) they just look sooo much better than well i guy it tw's which are kind of hard to not laugh at, they just make guys look sooo commical. guys it tight white shirts now there is something HOTTTTT! and will make you droooooollll

IP: Logged

Cat_on_my_head
Squishaholic
posted May 20, 2001 12:09 PM    
I have to say, I don't really care. Boxers are probably more attractive for lounging, but in the heat of the moment, they are just comming off, right? (Not that I would know. I am so virginal.)

IP: Logged

Beatrice
Forum Whore
posted May 20, 2001 06:25 PM    
I actually prefer tighty whities to boxers. I like to see ahint of what's underneath, so I like anything that's snuggish and holds the boys et al in a package for inspection, as well as defining the posterior. But really, it's up to the guy. Whatever he feels sexy in I'm bound to like.

IP: Logged


This topic is 5 pages long:   1  2  3  4  5 

All times are PT (US)

next newest topic | next oldest topic

Post New Topic  Post A Reply

Go Back